header

High Quality Sheltered Instruction
(HQSI)

homelessonsgraphic otipssiophotsmarzanodiff instructionprofabout_me

High Quality Sheltered Instruction is a model of instruction that is based on Sheltered Instruction Observation Protocol (SIOP), learning strategies by Robert Marzano, and differentiated learning strategies by Carol Tomlinson.

While the original intent of HQSI was to provide quality instruction to English language learners at the Clark County School District in Las Vegas, Nevada, we have found that this model of instruction has been beneficial to ALL students.

Sheltered Instruction Observation Protocol (SIOP)


vogtshortechevarria

Sheltered Instruction Observation Protocol began as a research project through the Center for Research on Education, Diversity & Excellence (CREDE) in 1993. The purpose of this research was to determine the impact of sheltered instruction on English language learners. This research, conducted by Echevarria, Vogt, and Short, attempted to determine whether or not grade-level content concepts were being effectively taught. By the year 2000, this research project bloomed into a model of instruction that has been adopted (and adapted) throughout the world.

This model of instruction includes eight components and 30 features that guide lesson plan development and instructional delivery. Let's take a look at each of these eight components:


1. Lesson Preparationlesson

Lesson Preparation | Background Information | Comprehensible Input | Strategies | Interaction | Practice & Application | Lesson Delivery | Review & Assessment | SIOP Lesson Plan | TOP

Teachers begin by determining objectives for their lesson. There rae two types of objectives: content objectives, which come from state standards or district benchmarks; and language objectives, which are determined from language arts standards. Think of content objectives as WHAT you will be teaching. Language objectives, on the other hand, state HOW students will prove that they understand the content objectives (are they going to read? write? listen? speak?).

Once objectives are determined, teachers then plan meaningful activities that will meet the objectives. Both the content and language objectives are posted (preferable in the same place every day) and spoken to the students so that both the students and teachers are clear on the focus of the lesson with the ultimate goal of the students mastering the content while growing in academic English. These objectives should be written in "student-friendly" vocabulary. The goal here is to remember that the objectives are a roadmap for the students. They need to understand what the expectations will be. Personally, I also have the students write the objectives in their daily journals as well. This helps to solidify the objectives in the students' minds as well as giving them practice writing in English. At the end of the lesson, the teacher and students can review the objectives to determine whether of not they met their goal for the day.

The concepts taught should be appropriate for the age and educational background of students. Teachers must consider the students' L1 literacy, second language proficiency, and the reading level of the materials. Supplementary materials are used to promote comprehension. These include charts, graphs, pictures, illustrations, realia, math manipulatives, multimedia, and demonstrations by either the teacher or other students.

The content must be adapted to meet the needs of ELLs through the use of graphic organizers, outlines, labeling of pictures, study guides, adapted text, and highlighted text. Meaningful activities integrate lesson concepts with language practice opportunities in the four domains: listening, speaking, reading, and writing.

Click here for a PowerPoint presentation on Lesson Preparation.



2. Building Background Knowledge:

Lesson Preparation | Background Information | Comprehensible Input | Strategies | Interaction | Practice & Application | Lesson Delivery | Review & Assessment | SIOP Lesson Plan | TOPbackground

In this component of the model, teachers connect the students' background and past experiences with the new learning. They help students comprehend by teaching the vocabulary that is key to understanding of the material. They explicitly teach the content vocabulary in areas such as ecosystems, coastal nations, and exploitation. Emphasis is placed on teaching the students the academic vocabulary that is so essential to understanding the content.

According to Saville-Troike (as quoted in Making Content Comprehensible for English Learners: The SIOP Model [2nd Ed.], p.49), "Vocabulary development is critical for English language learners because we know that there is a strong relationship between vocabulary knowledge in English and academic achievement."

Teachers use techniques to provide active involvement, personalize word learning, immerse students in words, and provide repeated exposure to words in more than one context. As a result of the in-depth teaching of the vocabulary, the students are better able to comprehend the content and further the development of their academic English.

The key to this component is that:

  1. Concepts should be directly linked to students' background experience - either personal, cultural, or academic.
  2. Links should be explicitly made between past learning and new concepts.Key vocabulary is emphasized.
  3. New vocabulary is presented in context, and the number of vocabulary words is limited. Research tells us that ELLs learn approximately 5 new words a day; therefore, we must choose our words wisely.

3. Comprehensible Inputunderstand

Lesson Preparation | Background Information | Comprehensible Input | Strategies | Interaction | Practice & Application | Lesson Delivery | Review & Assessment | SIOP Lesson Plan | TOP



In this component, teachers make lessons comprehensible by using vocabulary that the students understand, stating directions orally and in writing, and demonstrating what the students are expected to do. In addition, the students are given guided practice and are involved in a variety of techniques that provide hands-on practice. The students are provided with support such as prediction guides, visual aides, and other supplemental materials. The information is shared at an appropriate pace and enunciated clearly.

According to Echevarria, Vogt, and Short (p. 78), "Effective sheltered teachers provide explanations of academic tasks in ways that make clear what students are expected to accomplish and that promote student success."

The key in this component is that teachers:

  1. Introduce new learning in context
  2. Help students learn strategies such as predicting and summarizing
  3. Use speech that is appropriate for students' language proficiency
  4. Make explanations of tasks clear, using step-by-step directions with visuals
  5. Use a variety of techniques to make content concepts clear
  6. Focus attention selectively on the most important information

4. Strategies blooms2

Lesson Preparation | Background Information | Comprehensible Input | Strategies | Interaction | Practice & Application | Lesson Delivery | Review & Assessment | SIOP Lesson Plan | TOP

In this component, teachers use explicit instructional strategies, such as questioning techniques, to support higher-level thinking that involves predicting, summarizing, problem solving, organizing, evaluating, and self-monitoring. The instructional strategies also involve the students in scaffolding techniques that provide the right amount of support and help move the students to the next level. The students are given the time to practice the strategies with support from their peers and the teacher, as well as opportunities to implement the strategies independently. An example of a strategy encouraged in the SIOP model is the use of graphic organizers to assist students with visually organizing their learning. According to Echevarria, Vogt, & Short (who cite Fisher, Frey, & Williams, 2002; Pressley, 2000; Shearer, Ruddell & Vogt; and Slater & Horstman, 2002), "There is considerable evidence that teaching students a variety of self-regulating strategies improves student learning and reading."

The key in this component is that teachers:

  1. Provide ample opportunities for students to use learning strategies. Learning strategies should be taught through explicit instruction. You want students to develop independence in self-monitoring
  2. Consistent use of scaffolding techniques throughout the lesson. Introduce a new concept using a lot of scaffolding and decrease support as time goes on. Restate a student's response or use think-alouds
  3. Use of a variety of question types, including those that promote higher level thinking skills.

5. Interaction interaction

Lesson Preparation | Background Information | Comprehensible Input | Strategies | Interaction | Practice & Application | Lesson Delivery | Review & Assessment | SIOP Lesson Plan | TOP

In this component the teacher provides the students with continual opportunities to interact with peers through flexible grouping. Sometimes the students are in small groups, triads, or pairs where every student has an opportunity to speak and work on projects together. Through the various group activities, students are encouraged to interact with each other and have time for extended academic conversations with their peers. Teacher talk is reduced and the students are encouraged to talk more using academic language. Students are given adequate wait time so they can communicate their answers.

The key to this component is that teachers provide the following for ELLs:

  1. use of a variety of question types, including those that promote higher level thinking skills.
  2. frequent opportunities for interactions about lesson concepts which encourage higher level thinking skills.
  3. grouping which supports language and content objectives. Cooperative groups, buddies, pairs, large and small groups provide students with much needed "oral rehearsal" which, in turn, promotes better understanding.
  4. ample wait time for responses. Let other students write down answers while waiting for one student to respond .opportunities for clarification in native language, if possible. This could include bilingual paraprofessionals, native language materials, or notes by students.

6. Practice/Application 6

Lesson Preparation | Background Information | Comprehensible Input | Strategies | Interaction | Practice & Application | Lesson Delivery | Review & Assessment | SIOP Lesson Plan | TOP

This component of the SIOP model reinforces the importance of using hands-on material and manipulatives. Teachers plan small-group activities involving hands-on experiences that provide students with relevant information about the content and an opportunity to practice what they are learning. Echevarria, Vogt, & Short (p. 118) state that, "Manipulating learning materials is important for ELs because it helps them connect abstract concepts with concrete experiences." The students are provided opportunities to discuss and apply what they are learning through integration of reading, writing, listening, and speaking. By integrating all of the language arts areas, the ELs grow in their English language ability as well as learn the content.

The key aspects of this component is that lessons should include the following:

  1. hands-on materials or manipulatives for student practice.
  2. activities for students to apply content and language knowledge in the classroom.
  3. activities that integrate all language skills: listening, speaking, reading and writing.

7. Lesson Delivery7

Lesson Preparation | Background Information | Comprehensible Input | Strategies | Interaction | Practice & Application | Lesson Delivery | Review & Assessment | SIOP Lesson Plan | TOP

In the Lesson Delivery component the teacher focuses on the content and language objectives of the lesson and involves the students actively in meeting the objectives. Lessons are delivered at the appropriate pace so that the students can learn the material and not be bored. Students are engaged in the lesson 90% - 100% of time through well-planned lessons that are understandable to the students, create opportunities for students to talk about the concepts, and include hands-on activities that reinforce each lesson.

Remember:

  1. Content objectives are supported by lesson delivery. The objectives must be apparent throughout the lesson.
  2. Language objectives are supported by lesson delivery. Students must be given ample opportunities to "show off" their language capabilities in speaking, reading, and writing.
  3. Students are engaged 90% to 100% of the period. Provide less "teacher talk", no "down time"; students are actively working in whole groups, small groups, or individually.
  4. Pacing of the lesson is appropriate to students’ ability level.

8. Review/Assessment assess

Lesson Preparation | Background Information | Comprehensible Input | Strategies | Interaction | Practice & Application | Lesson Delivery | Review & Assessment | SIOP Lesson Plan | TOP

In the Review/Assessment component of SIOP, the teachers provide the appropriate feedback so that the students can continue to grow, review the key concepts to ensure long-lasting learning, and provide assessment to track student progress. The teachers are involved in the "Effective Teaching Cycle for ELs," which includes the following steps:

  1. Provide comprehensive review of key vocabulary. (teach, review, assess, reteach; use word study books, content word walls, etc.)
  2. Provide comprehensive review of key content concepts. (review content directly related to objectives throughout the lesson; use graphic organizers as review...)
  3. Regularly provide feedback to students on their output, e.g., language, content, work. ( clarify, discuss, correct responses)
  4. Conduct assessments of student comprehension and learning of all lesson objectives (e.g., spot checking, group response) throughout the lesson. (use a variety of quick reviews: thumbs up-thumbs down, numbered wheels, small dry erase boards, student self-assessment).

Lesson Preparation | Background Information | Comprehensible Input | Strategies | Interaction | Practice & Application | Lesson Delivery | Review & Assessment | SIOP Lesson Plan | TOP

SIOP Lesson Plan Outline with Guidelines

Standards - Select standards from your state or district standards and benchmarks.

Theme - Think of the broad understanding that the lesson includes, such as cooperation, courage, environment, justice, perseverance, or diversity.

Lesson Topic - What is the lesson about? For example, protecting coral reefs.

Content Objectives - What will the students know and be able to do as a result of this lesson? For example: Students will understand the fragility of coral reefs... or Students will form an opinion as to how to protect coral reefs.

Language Objectives - How will listening, speaking, reading, and writing be included in the lesson? For example, students will READ information about the coral reefs; ORALLY STATE one or more ways coral reefs can be preserved; SUMMARIZE their opinion in writing.

Leaning Strategies - Select a strategy or strategies that will assist and support student understanding. For example, teach the students to use the "gist" (Muth & Alvermann, 1999) method which assists students in summarizing. Steps for this strategy include the following:

The students now have a summary paragraph.

Key Vocabulary - Select a few vocabulary words that are essential to the understanding of the material to be taught as well as the academic words needed to process the concepts. Provide user-friendly definitions, examples of the words from different contexts, multiple exposures, and active involvement with the words.

Materials - List what you will need in order to teach the lesson. Things like paper, pencils, chart paper, pictures, etc.

LESSON SEQUENCE:

Motivation - (Building background knowledge; links to background and to past learning)

Presentation - (Content and language objectives, comprehensible input, strategies, interaction, feedback, modeling)

Practice/Application - (Meaningful activities, interaction, strategies, guided and independent practice, feedback)

Review/Assessment - (Review objectives and vocabulary, assess learning [individual, group, written, oral])

Extension - Assign "big idea" questions that relate to the topic for homework, such as, 'Why do you think...?


References:

Bilingual and Compensator Education Resource Team (2002), Dearborn Public Schools, Dearborn Michigan.

Echevarria, Vogt, and Short, Making Content COmprehensible for English Learners, 2004, Pearson.

Hanson, Susan, and Filibert, Consius (Fall, 2006), "Teaching English Learners the SIOP Way", Pacific Resources for Education and Learning, pp 12-14.